Answer first: You do not have to share your number because someone asks. It is fine to say you would like to keep chatting on the app for now, and to share it later when you are comfortable. How someone responds to that is one useful signal, alongside the checks on their profile.
The chat is going well, and the other person asks for your number. Their profile has a selfie badge. You would like to keep talking and would feel more comfortable doing it on the app for now. A simple reply is enough. “I’m enjoying this. I’d like to keep chatting here for a bit.”
Why this comes up so often
Global Dating Insights reported on an August 2026 Harris Poll of 892 single adults in the United States, commissioned by World, a verification provider. In that survey, 81% said they would be much more likely to use a dating app if every profile was confirmed as belonging to a real person. Among respondents who had used dating apps, 74% said they had suspected that someone they connected with was not real. Sources: Global Dating Insights coverage and World’s survey results and methodology.
Keep in mind who paid for that poll. A verification company has an interest in the answer. Even so, the second figure is worth noting: among the dating-app users surveyed, most had wondered at some point whether the person on the other end was who they said they were.
Read the check under the badge
On HoopFrog, you can see the individual checks alongside a Trust Score out of 100. A confirmed phone number means the member had access to a number they could confirm. A selfie badge means a live selfie was compared with a profile photo. Photo screening is a check at upload for issues such as inappropriate content.
Each of those tells you one specific thing. None of them tells you what somebody wants from you. Look at the checks one by one, then decide how comfortable you feel continuing the conversation. We explain the differences in ID, phone and photo verification compared and in HoopFrog’s guide to profile checks.
Pay attention to the reply
Someone can ask for your number because texting is more convenient. You learn more from what they do after you say you would prefer to stay on the app. “Sure, no rush” gives you room to get to know them. Repeated requests, or a claim that you have to switch apps straight away, give you a reason to pause.
Some requests are not a matter of pace at all. If they send a link to “verify” your account, ask for a code that arrived by text, or ask you to send money, stop and report the account. Keep verification codes and financial details to yourself. Our list of red flags to spot early covers the patterns that tend to come next.
Keep the conversation where you have controls
You can message a mutual connection for free on HoopFrog without sharing your number. Messages are checked for common scam patterns. If HoopFrog flags a message for a possible scam, the person receiving it may see a warning. No warning does not mean a message is safe, so trust your own read as well.
You can also report or block someone from their profile or your chat. If the conversation feels off, use those controls even when the profile shows completed checks. Once you give out a phone number you cannot take it back, and reports made through HoopFrog’s own tools are the ones our team can review.
A middle step before you swap numbers
If you want more than text but are not ready to hand over your number, suggest a short voice or video call inside the app. Calls inside HoopFrog are available with VIP. A few minutes of live conversation can answer questions a week of messages cannot, and an in-app call lets you talk without sharing your phone number. We wrote about how to set one up in why a video call before you meet is worth it.
When you do decide to share it
There is no correct number of days. Share your number when you would be comfortable with this person being able to reach you directly, and not before. If you are curious about what the checks look like, open the example profile on our home page and look beneath the introduction. Then you will know what to look for the next time someone asks. See an example HoopFrog profile, or read HoopFrog’s dating safety guide.
Common questions
Should I give my phone number to someone I met on a dating app?
Only when you are comfortable. There is no set number of messages or days. Staying on the app keeps reporting, blocking and message checks available, and someone who respects that choice is showing you one good sign.
Why do people ask to move off the app so quickly?
Often it is simply convenience. It can also be a way to move a conversation somewhere with no moderation and no record. One request tells you little. Repeated pressure after you have said you would like to stay on the app is the part to pay attention to.
Does a selfie badge mean the person is safe?
No. On HoopFrog a selfie badge means a live selfie was compared with a profile photo. It says nothing about someone’s intentions. Read each check for what it covers, and keep using your own judgement.
What should I do if someone asks me for a verification code?
Do not share it. A code sent to your phone is for you alone. Anyone asking for one, or sending you a link to “verify” your account, should be reported and blocked.